Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Josh Edelman

Josh Edelman has started 53 posts and replied 173 times.

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Josh Edelman:
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Josh Edelman:
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Josh Edelman:

I want to buy my next investment. Looking for advice on way forward. Here is the skinny: 

- I have one rental property (VA loan)

- took out a Heloc to buy my second property 

- I live in the second property (VA loan also)

- I've used up my VA loan limit

- I have $50k saved for a down payment 

- I live in Las Vegas and don’t mind investing out of state 

- Best advice for third property? 25% down conventional out of state? Move out to a primary residence on a third property? 

- goal is not to sell the current two - they cash flow well 


Thanks! 
 


Refi #1 into a conventional. Yes, rates are higher BUT given you have a strong equity position, that should help mitigate that rate a touch. And it unlocks VA for #3.


 Unfortunately I would be cash flow negative if I refinanced. Is that still your recommendation? I currently pay $1200/month. New mortgage would be $2300/mo. 


Is the $1,100 difference from wrapping the heloc in and new conventional rate? 

If you have that heloc with a balance, your not ready for the next one. You need to clear that acquisition $. 


 Sorry let me clarify:
The current mortgage is $1200
The heloc payment is $500
The new mortgage with a 6.5% conventional would probably be closer to $2300 

I'm not sure what would be better - wrap the heloc into the rate or just pay it off from the cash out refi. 

 Ok Josh, understand what I am advising from has a basis in 2 different foundation points. The first is market cycles, the second is investor psychology. 

I would say you need to pay-off that heloc, full-stop. Not interrelated to a purchase, just pay that off. Because think, that was your down payment on a property. You borrowed that down, so you must have that as priority #1 of paying for that down. A down is supposed to be cash in hand. 

I get what your thinking, but this is not the market cycle for that. Your looking at using maximum leverage, and this is NOT the time for maximum leverage, it is time for being DE-leveraged. 

And on the investor psychology side of things, you gotta keep in mind that down $, that's cash-in-hand. $ used to secure a property, and borrowing for it is "cheating". So, you need to feel a kind of anxiety associated with that, and a burning desire to get that paid and cleared ASAP. 

When one thinks like this, it helps align the mind to keep a focus on proper production of property. It put's you in a mindset to keep driving at delivering cash-flow, in general. 

We are in STAGFLATION tail-spin, with powers that be pressing for recession to prevent stagflation. Many bad things can result from such for the heavily leveraged person. My #2 money-maker in last tight economic cycle, was buying out failed investors. All of them had same story, the leveraged tight as a nats-azz, and then something happened, something they did not have a buffer to fall back upon, and next thing there deep in the red with no way to turn. Don't be that guy. 

Todays market is about VERY smart acquisition, with ample margins, contingency funds, contingency for contingency. 

I know your licking those chops at #3, but what's most important is to keep going vs pumping unit count to just loose it all, or any, right. 

The #'s are clear, you gotta take a step back, clear that borrowed down $. Now your way better set to convert mortgages when do AND have a contingency fund when/if need in the interim. 

Keep in mind, cash in hand is dyeing at about 8% right now (inflation). Paying off heloc removes that interest charge AND loss of $ via inflation. So if heloc is say 6%, that's a 14% saving your affecting. Because Real Estate moves with inflation, right, so $ in real estate is at net 0 to inflation. That's 0 vs -8. So paying off heloc should be viewed as a 14% ROI. That's smart $, is it not.

So take it in smart steps. Stop thinking about #3, think about stabilizing what you got, to be best set to jump on #3. 


 James - this is fantastic feedback. Thank you for breaking this down. Just so I am clear, this is what I understand from your recommendation:

- Pay off the HELOC - use my cash on hand to do so
(I can't pay it in full but I can do it in chunks - do you have a recommendation?)
- If I pay off the HELOC right now with cash I have saved I would be at an overall loss since I would have used up all my cash plus what I have been earning from my rental property the past year.

Overall, clear the HELOC before trying to buy #3 correct?

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Josh Edelman:
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Josh Edelman:

I want to buy my next investment. Looking for advice on way forward. Here is the skinny: 

- I have one rental property (VA loan)

- took out a Heloc to buy my second property 

- I live in the second property (VA loan also)

- I've used up my VA loan limit

- I have $50k saved for a down payment 

- I live in Las Vegas and don’t mind investing out of state 

- Best advice for third property? 25% down conventional out of state? Move out to a primary residence on a third property? 

- goal is not to sell the current two - they cash flow well 


Thanks! 
 


Refi #1 into a conventional. Yes, rates are higher BUT given you have a strong equity position, that should help mitigate that rate a touch. And it unlocks VA for #3.


 Unfortunately I would be cash flow negative if I refinanced. Is that still your recommendation? I currently pay $1200/month. New mortgage would be $2300/mo. 


Is the $1,100 difference from wrapping the heloc in and new conventional rate? 

If you have that heloc with a balance, your not ready for the next one. You need to clear that acquisition $. 


 Sorry let me clarify:
The current mortgage is $1200
The heloc payment is $500
The new mortgage with a 6.5% conventional would probably be closer to $2300 

I'm not sure what would be better - wrap the heloc into the rate or just pay it off from the cash out refi. 

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @Sam McCormack:

@Josh Edelman

Hi Josh, I am an agent in Cincinnati, OH and I think Cincinnati has what you need! Cash flow AND appreciation, low purchase price, etc. Let me know what you think, I would love to answer any question you may have!


 I'd be interested to see what's going down! 

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @James Hamling:
Quote from @Josh Edelman:

I want to buy my next investment. Looking for advice on way forward. Here is the skinny: 

- I have one rental property (VA loan)

- took out a Heloc to buy my second property 

- I live in the second property (VA loan also)

- I've used up my VA loan limit

- I have $50k saved for a down payment 

- I live in Las Vegas and don’t mind investing out of state 

- Best advice for third property? 25% down conventional out of state? Move out to a primary residence on a third property? 

- goal is not to sell the current two - they cash flow well 


Thanks! 
 


Refi #1 into a conventional. Yes, rates are higher BUT given you have a strong equity position, that should help mitigate that rate a touch. And it unlocks VA for #3.


 Unfortunately I would be cash flow negative if I refinanced. Is that still your recommendation? I currently pay $1200/month. New mortgage would be $2300/mo. 

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @Robin Simon:
Quote from @Josh Edelman:
Quote from @Eliott Elias:

This is up to you and what your investment goals are. If lending is your constraint there are DSCR loans that will allow you to take as many loans as you want as long as the property cash flows. Hoping to use your VA loan for investment property will handicap you.

Thanks! I've gone through one lender for a DSCR loan, however DSCR rates were extremely high making anything cashflow negative. Do I keep shopping for other lenders for DSCR or find another strategy? Very very tough to get these rates down of course. 

What rates have you been seeing on your DSCR quotes? The market has been quite volatile and if you are putting 25% down then if your credit is solid a lot of deals are cash flowing again on DSCR, especially if you pick the right market

9-10%

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:

How much equity do you have in the current properties?


 Not much, combined probably $80K

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @Adah N.:

@Josh Edelman

Do you have a wife and/or kids? If not, another owner occupied property is probably the easiest and least expensive way to get a 3rd property. It needs to be a a good investment property to buy and hold i.e it will appreciate and cash flow when you move out and rent.


 Thanks Adah! I do not. I have a girlfriend who is moving in with me. I will consider this option. Thank you! 

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @Eliott Elias:

This is up to you and what your investment goals are. If lending is your constraint there are DSCR loans that will allow you to take as many loans as you want as long as the property cash flows. Hoping to use your VA loan for investment property will handicap you.

Thanks! I've gone through one lender for a DSCR loan, however DSCR rates were extremely high making anything cashflow negative. Do I keep shopping for other lenders for DSCR or find another strategy? Very very tough to get these rates down of course. 

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135
Quote from @Larry Turowski:

@Josh Edelman congrats on your first two!  I’m in Las Vegas right now and could tell you all about Rochester for your third!

I don’t care to gamble. Funny thing, I was just telling someone, why gamble when I can win 90% of the time with real estate? (And it’s really higher than that.)

Thanks Larry! I'd love to connect if you don't mind. I'm an agent in Vegas but I'd be all ears to hear about Rochester. Thanks again!

Post: Getting my Third Property? I’m stuck

Josh EdelmanPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Las Vegas
  • Posts 189
  • Votes 135

I want to buy my next investment. Looking for advice on way forward. Here is the skinny: 

- I have one rental property (VA loan)

- took out a Heloc to buy my second property 

- I live in the second property (VA loan also)

- I've used up my VA loan limit

- I have $50k saved for a down payment 

- I live in Las Vegas and don’t mind investing out of state 

- Best advice for third property? 25% down conventional out of state? Move out to a primary residence on a third property? 

- goal is not to sell the current two - they cash flow well 


Thanks!