Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Paul Novak

Paul Novak has started 21 posts and replied 146 times.

Post: New to the forum!

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109
Quote from @Arvin Digma:

Hey guys! I'm a real estate investor based out of San Diego, and I currently own a duplex in Vista. Super excited to connect with other investors here and share experiences. I've been diving into real estate for a while now and always love meeting others who are navigating this crazy, but rewarding, journey.

Looking forward to learning from everyone, swapping ideas, and hearing about different strategies you all are using. Whether it's about deals, property management, or anything in between, I'm all in for a good conversation!


 I agree with you, I have only been at this for a little over 3 years and I love doing this.  I own 5 properties two of them being multi family properties so 7 doors.  I am following the small and mighty approach and also have loved connecting with people.  If you have any specific questions you are looking to connect on let me know and I would be happy to share what I have learned up to this point.

Post: Question regarding debt consolidation

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109
Quote from @Carlos Richardson:

Hello Team,

I am  looking at my outstanding credit card debt which is at ~25k would it make sense for me to consolidate this debt to a lower interest loan? 

Any advice or pointers would be greatly appreciated!

thx

Carlos Richardson


 Mathematically this normally makes sense but I get nervous giving people advice to do this.  I say it depends on what your plan is to pay it off and how long you anticipating it taking to pay it off.  Many times I tell my friends to just keep the debt, bite the bullet, and pay it off.  I have seen many consolidate their debt using a lower interest loan only to rack the credit card right back up and still have the loan.

Post: Best place to put money for saving for a house?

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109

Emmy,


For me I would put money like that in a high yield savings account because when I start saving for a shorter term goal I want to be able to use the growth to help me save.  The other thing I use for savings is my cash position in my taxable brokerage account which right now is getting 4.5% interest.  For me doing this gives me the flexibility that if something comes up I could use this savings in two ways for emergencies and for my savings goal.

I have in the past taken more risk and put the money in low cost index funds within my taxable brokerage account like VOO but there is risk here.  Your money could grow at 20% for the year and they could go down in value 20% for the year.  This year the market is up 21.09%, last year the market was down 13.04%, 2021 the market was up 39.44%.  My wife and I have two reliable vehicles but I decided when they were paid off to start saving right away for the next one by making car payments to myself.  I have put all that money in VOO over the past 3 years and the results have been great but there is risk.

I think this is all about risk tolerance.  If you have more specific questions let me know.

Post: Small & Mighty Real Estate Investing

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109
Quote from @Drago Stanimirovic:

Hi Paul,

You're in a strong position with your portfolio, and both strategies have their advantages. Here’s a streamlined perspective:

Your current approach, putting more down upfront, minimizes risk, increases cash flow faster, and allows you to build equity while reducing overall interest. This aligns well with your goal of achieving $11K/month in cash flow and retiring within 5-10 years. It also gives you stability in the event of market downturns or unexpected expenses, allowing you to lower rents if needed without feeling financial pressure.

The alternative leveraging more with 20% down—would allow you to acquire properties more quickly, accelerating your cash flow goal. You’d benefit from faster appreciation, tax benefits, and rental increases. However, this increases your exposure to risk, especially in terms of vacancy, repairs, or market shifts. Lower immediate cash flow and higher mortgage payments would extend the timeline for paying off properties and add interest over time.

In essence, it’s about balancing risk and speed. If your focus is on minimizing risk and ensuring consistent cash flow, your current strategy works. But if you’re comfortable taking on more leverage to acquire properties faster, the second approach can help you reach your goals sooner. A hybrid approach purchasing a few more properties with 20% down while paying off existing loans, might give you the best of both worlds.

Let me know if you need any further guidance on running numbers or fine-tuning your strategy.

Best,

Drago


 Drago,

Thanks for your perspective and taking the time to reach out.

Post: Expense and mileage tracking for real estate

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109
Quote from @Shari B.:

Any recommendations for a free or inexpensive app for tracking expenses and mileage? New to real estate and hoping for a simple way to track. Thank you!


 I know it's not specific software for mileage or book keeping but I have 4 properties, have been doing this for 3 years, and just made a simple google sheet to track everything.  Below show some screen shots of what we give to our accountant and this works for him.  We also save paper copies of all of our receipts.  The only thing he told us to do is track expenses and income per property vs. on one large sheet.  Hopefully this helps.

Post: Small & Mighty Real Estate Investing

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109
Quote from @Lotus Eli:

I know this may sound simple and unorthodox, but I think you should try to BRRRR as much as possible. By using the BRRRR strategy, you only need to put down money once. After that initial down payment, the bank will basically be financing your investments. You'd buy an off-market, distressed property, fix it up, rent it out, refinance it, collect your money from the refinance, and repeat the process. This way, you only need to invest your profits once.

Overall, I don’t think you should keep buying more properties and making down payments repeatedly. That approach involves a lot of work and spending, and there are better strategies to utilize. By BRRRRing, you can achieve your goal of acquiring four houses with minimal effort and financial strain, allowing you to shift from buying to paying them off. Plus, you’d probably reach your goals faster with that plan of attack if executed properly. I hope this provides some value to you.

Lotus


 Thanks for the feedback, this is something I may have to look into.  I know about the strategy but have never yet put it to use.

Post: Seeking Advice on Using Retirement Funds for Real Estate Investment

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109
Quote from @Daniel M.:

Thank you to everyone for your input! Here's the summary of opinions:

  • Against: 7
  • For: 4
  • Neutral/Alternative: 5

My New Plan:

Instead of cashing out my IRA/401(k), I'm considering borrowing from my 401(k). Here's the breakdown:

  • Loan Amount: $50,000 (max allowable amount)
  • Interest Rate: 9.5% (interest goes back into the 401(k))
  • Repayment: $524.24 twice a month over 60 months (max allowable time)
  • Total Repayment: $62,908.67 (including $12,908.67 in interest)
  • Fees: $75 setup fee + $6.25 quarterly fee (totaling $206.25)

Additionally, I have a taxable brokerage account with a modest capital gain and a tax rate of 15%.

Total Funds for Investment:

Combining the $50,000 loan with the funds from the brokerage account, I’ll have the down payment for another property.

I’m excited about this new plan and looking forward to your thoughts and advice!


 Very cool Daniel!!!!  I am excited for you and hope all goes well.  As I stated this strategy has worked great for us I hope the same for you.

Post: A Balanced Life? - Tracking Expenses

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109
Quote from @Ahmed Aboelela:

G’day

How do you track your expenses and find a balance between being a spendthrift and being too conservative? What does that middle ground look like for you?         

Many Thanks

Ahmed Aboelela


 I have been working at my budget for years.  How I have found my middle ground is with time.  My budget in the beginning was really tight because it was based on the money we made at the time and debt payments.  There wasn't much left over.  With time we paid off debt and lowered our expenses.  At the same time our income grew.  This allowed us to increase our savings and increase our spending.  Every time that happened we increased our savings by 75% of the difference and our spending by 25% until our spending hit a level that we were comfortable with.  At which point we diverted 100% of future increase into savings.  We now budget for vacations, home improvements, car savings, medical savings, Christmas fund, etc... 

Post: Seeking Advice on Using Retirement Funds for Real Estate Investment

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109
Quote from @Daniel M.:

I'm considering cashing out my 401(k) and IRA funds to invest in more real estate and would appreciate any advice or insights on whether this idea is viable.

Current Financial Situation:

  • Significant savings in 401(k) and IRA accounts.
  • Additional funds in a taxable brokerage account.
  • Age: 40, with a relatively high effective tax rate.
  • Limited emergency fund.

Existing Duplex:

  • Mortgage with a 75% LTV ratio and a high interest rate.
  • Modest annual cash flow.

Withdrawal Scenarios:

  • Scenario 1: Withdraw everything today at age 40, resulting in a 35% loss to penalties and taxes.
  • Scenario 2: Withdraw at age 60 with growth scenarios ranging from 1.3x to 2.3x the initial balance.

Proposed Real Estate Investment:

  • Purchase two additional duplexes with a 75% LTV and 6.635% interest rate on a 30-year term.
  • Projected outcomes include appreciation, cash flow growth, loan amortization, and tax benefits.

Comparison of Real Estate vs. Retirement Accounts:

  • Conservative estimates suggest real estate investment could more than double the value compared to leaving funds in retirement accounts.
  • Best-case scenario projects nearly three times the value through appreciation, rental income, mortgage paydown, and tax benefits.

Conclusion: Investing retirement funds in real estate offers significant potential for financial growth and diversification. Despite risks, the projected returns surpass those of traditional retirement accounts.

Seeking Advice: I would like your advice on whether using my retirement funds for real estate investment is a good idea, considering the potential risks, returns, tax implications, and any alternative strategies.

Thank you for your help!


 I have used retirement funds for real estate to allow me to continue growing, specifically my 401K.  I wouldn't recommend this for most people but my real estate portfolio is going to be used for my retirement anyways so I see it as shifting funds from one retirement account to another.  I wouldn't do this to fund personal expenses or growing my lifestyle.  I didn't want to pay penalties or excess taxes so I took a loan out against my 401K.  I am not sure how much money you have in the account but the rules with my employer was that I could borrow 50% of the account value or $50K, which ever amount was smaller.  Because my account value is at $280K I could pull out the $50K.  The cost of me to do this was a one time fee of $75.  The terms were a 5 year loan at 8.25% but the interest gets paid back to my 401K so I keep the interest.  I paid it back by payroll deduction of $489 per paycheck coming off my check going to pay back the loan.  My wife and I have a solid income and good saving habits so we paid the loan back in 10 months.  Then I did it again for my next property.  We continue to alternate between doing this with my wife's account, pay it back, then do my account to continue scaling.  I am 39 with 4 properties.  This option has been working good for us and avoids penalties and taxes.  The opportunity costs are the reduction in cashflow from your paycheck while you payback the loan, and your 401K having stunted growth while the money is borrowed against it.  Not sure if this is an option that would work for you but it's something to consider.  If you have more questions feel free to reach back out to me.

Post: 401K Investment Feedback

Paul Novak
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Wisconsin
  • Posts 146
  • Votes 109

I am looking for some advice based on what others in the community have done with their 401K’s. My first investment ever made was my 401K. At one point my wife and I were putting 15% into our 401K’s. The more I learned about personal finance and investing the more I knew how important this account was and continued to focus on growing my contributions. That was before I got into real estate. I now see real estate as my way to retirement. My strategy best aligns with the small and mighty real estate investors. My portfolio is currently 4 properties 6 doors. My ultimate goal is to generate $11K per month in passive income and I believe I can do that by purchasing 3 more single family homes in my area and paying off the entire portfolio. Based on our current income levels I should be able to accomplish this goal in the next 10 years and I am 39 now.

My question to the group is what to do with my 401K. To increase my capital for investing I have already scaled our 401K contributions back to 6% to take advantage of the company match and aren’t doing any more than that. We have also started using our 401K’s to take loans out to purchase properties. I have decided that I would rather borrow from myself and pay myself back interest vs. the bank. The next step I am considering is stopping contributing all together and putting that capital into our real estate investments. This would give us about an extra $14K a year today to invest and as our income grows so will that number. Today we invest 100% into Roth contributions so there is no tax benefits to diverting the funds I would just be giving up the $7K a year employer match. Today my wife and I have around $500K in our accounts combined. By my calculations and I, correct me if I am wrong, but if those accounts grow by 7% per year on average and we stop contributing that $500K will turn into about $1.9M in 20 years when I can start pulling it out. If our rental portfolio is already sustaining our living, why do I even need that extra $1.9M. Even if it’s only $1M I think I would be okay in stopping our contributions. Am I missing something?